Just when you thought the New York Times’ accounts of the NCAA’s inquiry into minor Tennessee recruiting violations couldn’t blow this situation any more out of proportion, their long-time columnist, George Vecsey, decides to take a stab at it:
Hostesses as recruiters: How far is too far?
Holy mountains out of molehills, Batman!
I hardly know how to begin. Let’s just start at the top:
Just when I was getting all soppy about some student-athletes I encountered last week, I read about a recruiting scandal at the University of Tennessee.
“Scandal?” Seriously? Two college girls took a trip to watch some high school boys play ball. It’s apparently going to be a secondary (read: minor) recruiting violation. Most schools have a few of those a year. Ohio State has had more than 300 this decade. Scandal, George? Let’s get real. If it turns out that someone in the Athletic Department at Tennessee asked these girls to go on a recruiting trip, or reimbursed them for the trip, then it could be a major violation. And I would be first in line to call for whoever was responsible to be fired. Even if it was Lane Kiffin. Even if it was Mike Hamilton.
Meanwhile, it has been alleged that former LSU receivers coach DJ McCarthy paid a recruit to sign with LSU. Paying an amateur athlete to attend your school . . . now that’s a serious violation, George. Where’s the onslaught of stories from your paper about the situation in Baton Rouge? Only in the NYT is a couple of girls holding a sign more important than paying a player to sign. And some folks wonder why the NYT is paving the road to Irrelevance.
Maybe you saw the photograph at SI.com, with the two poised young women, with their rigid beauty-queen smiles, posing with a couple of high school prospects a couple of states away.
Somebody get George a map. Tennessee and South Carolina are separated by mountains, not a couple of states.
I’m not suggesting anything untoward happened on the little trip from Knoxville, Tenn., to Duncan, S.C.
Of course you’re not, George.
I’m sure the two young women were there just to wish the lads well and say, “If you’re ever in the neighborhood, y’all come see us, y’heah?”
Oh, goodie. Now we’re to the part where the Yankee reporter makes fun of Southern stereotypes.
It sounds like a major state university encouraging two undergraduates to send an unmistakable message: “These are the kind of honeys we have in Knoxville.” Athletes want to know this before they matriculate.
It’s a good thing the NCAA doesn’t contract George to do its investigations. Tennessee would already be on probation. It’s interesting that local media have thus far been unable to turn up evidence that this major state university encouraged the girls to go to the game, but a columnist sitting “a couple of states away” determined it just by reading a couple of news accounts.
Oh, and about that judging the “honeys” before you matriculate thing. You did catch the point that the two players whose names were on the signs—Miller and Willis—have already verbally committed to play at Tennessee. You did catch that part didn’t you, George? So if the scandalous Athletic Department down here—sorry, down “heah”—wanted to encourage girls to recruit, why wouldn’t they send them to south Florida? We’re hot on the trail of a couple of big-name recruits down there and our guy in charge of that area just accepted a better job at Florida State. We could use all the help we could get down there thehe.
By the way, I am no Tennessee-basher.
Of course you’re not, George. Of course you’re not. Y’all like it down heah, don’t you?
The Web tells me that Interstate 40 is cut off by a rock slide west of Asheville, N.C. (I am not making this up)
George, if you had bothered to research before writing (I know, it’s such a quaint little concept), you would’ve discovered that the I-40 rock slide occurred on Oct. 25. That was a full month after the hostesses attended the game in South Carolina.
Actually don’t know how the hostesses got to the high school football game. Maybe they were flown on a private jet donated by some fat-cat Tennessee Vols booster.
Yeah, maybe they were. And maybe George Vecsey has been paid by one of Tennessee’s rivals to write a hit piece on the Vols. Hey, why not? I have just as much proof as you have.
“My observation is that this is a very organized operation,” Easterwood said. “These girls have obviously been groomed. There’s a lot of eye contact and touching.”
Let’s drag out the Easterwood comments again, accusing a university of an organized effort to turn college girls into sexual deviants who hit on recruits and their fathers. We still haven’t seen mention of the fact that this wouldn’t be the first time Easterwood falsely accused an SEC school of recruiting violations (Arkansas, 2005), and this is apparently the only source the NYT has to corroborate an outrageous claim. But, what the heck. Let’s not let that stop us from a good juicy story.
Could the N.C.A.A. mandate an autumn without the sound of “Rocky Top” echoing off the hills? Could happen. Maybe should happen.
That can’t be right. I gotta reread this again.
Could the N.C.A.A. mandate an autumn without the sound of “Rocky Top” echoing off the hills? Could happen. Maybe should happen.
Oh my. Yeah, he really did say it. He’s suggesting that Tennessee could and should receive the NCAA’s “death penalty” for what is very likely to amount to a secondary recruiting violation. LOL George! A little hyperbolic, aren’t we?
| Print article | This entry was posted by BenG. on December 15, 2009 at 1:54 pm, and is filed under Football. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed. |
about 8 months ago
Geez. Here is my question: Do football recruits actually read that garbage and buy into it? I have read a lot of stupid stuff in my day but that pretty much takes the cake. The whole cake. And licks the bowl.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
I am not familiar with George Vecsey, but I am familiar with the NYTimes, which I read daily for a rich variety of news, generally presented in a professional manner. If this column is typical of what he writes, I am not at all surprised that The Times is laying off people and losing readers. I have been a journalist for more than 40 years and what Mr. Vecsey is passing for column writing is sophomoric, baseless, bigoted and stupid. It should never have passed the first round on the copy desk and certainly should never have made the pages of a paper that considers itself the center of the civilized universe. Maybe Mr. Vecsey mailed this one in. Even the vaunted New York library system takes Sunday off and still manages to think it is right there next to The Times at the center of everything of importance.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Ben, this is a great dissection of an idiotic piece from the Gray Granny. I’ve admired your work locally and it’s nice to see you get some props and a link from the KNS. Of course, your work is better than most of the stuff that they pass off as journalism also.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Ben,
You need to get a map. TN is separated by the state of NC from SC. And depending how you drive you might have to go the GA
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Ben,
You need to get a map. TN is separated by the state of NC from SC. And depending how you drive you might have to go thru GA as well
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
RonO,
Really; out of that whole story the only thing you bring up is geography.
Let’s see…….on what parallel did the girls leave from and then end up on? Which GPS did they use and did Tom-Tom make them go 13.646392 mi. out of the way? Did the girls stop to pee on the trip? Were they seen at the Beacon? Sweet tea or not?
What a weird grasp you have on the story.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Ron O?!? GreggO?!? Really?!? Just change the first name and no boby can figure out that u r the dsame person?!? Is this a Clark Kent / Superman kind of thing?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Yeah! Even though he can’t type, I agree with URaDumbAss!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Yeah, I agree with URaDumbAss, too!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
George is a Tennessee Homeboy – born in New York, New York – lives in Long Island, but he once came to Tennessee and found the last farm in the state without power. He knows us better than we know ourselves. …and I guess he got a Dolly Parton tape at the Pilot to show his friends back home. Why just to show us what a Tennessee guy he is, I bet he even slept with his sister.
Hey George, please don’t notice that we have world reknown supercomputing, Oak Ridge National Labratory, one of the top nuclear engineering programs, the best forensic’s program in the country, cutting edge technology, business and research… That wouldn’t fit your sterotype. Nope, all the NYT readers need to have you reaffirm the stupid sterotypes of the south and Tennessee. Just keep thinking we are all stupid, slow thinking, daughter pimping, inbreeders. We’ll keep to our hard working values that are attracting companies like VW, Toyota, Honda, Mercedes, NUCOR and other companies to our area while the rest of the world continues to call YOU the RUST BELT. My guess that is an observation of your mental abilities as well as your industrial might.
You know George, the other point you CLEARLY never stopped to consider is that perhaps these two young ladies met these two guys and actually made friends with them. I know, I know – you look at that picture and see race, and think the “Well, this is the South isn’t it…” You don’t even have the objectivity to consider the possibility that this is all legit. …could it be that you are the racist?
You also fail to mention that the Coach in Memphis is now refusing to talk to the NCAA??? Could it be that he was just talking some trash and now doesn’t want to go on the record???
Do you have any integrity at all? I mean, don’t you feel bad when you have a deadline and you aren’t sure what to write so you just half way do your job and write something so poorly thought out and constructed as this?
Love from Tennessee…
Like or Dislike:
0
0
about 8 months ago
Hey Ron-O,
Yes TN is seperated by NC from SC but look at that map your telling Ben to look at and tell me, if you were gonna write a story would you say 2 STATES away or seperated by the Smokey Mtns. He’s just trying to show that 2 states can be taken differently considering the trip was shorter than a trip from Knox to Nash. Get a life you pinhead!
Like or Dislike:
0
0